
By Erica Arrechea | Founder of Cinqe Matchmaking | Professional Matchmaker Since 2010
Should a man take a woman to dinner on a first date, or is meeting for drinks perfectly acceptable?
I’ve been a professional matchmaker for 16 years, and I cannot tell you how many times this conversation has come up.
Men ask me whether dinner is too much of a commitment. Women tell me they’re tired of being invited out for a quick drink. And everyone seems to have an opinion about what a first date should look like.
So I decided to ask our newsletter and Instagram audience.
The results were surprisingly close.
1,437 singles participated in the poll.
Dinner won, but not by much!
And after 16 years of arranging dates for successful singles, I have a few thoughts about why.

I work with successful men and women across the United States and internationally. Many of our clients are executives, entrepreneurs, business owners, and professionals with demanding schedules.
One thing I’ve learned is that women often interpret the first date as an indication of how much effort a man is willing to make.
A dinner reservation communicates something.
It says he planned ahead. He selected a restaurant. He made a reservation. He set aside time to get to know her.
Now, does that mean every woman expects a five-star restaurant and a $500 dinner?
Absolutely not.
But there is something attractive about a man who takes initiative.
I constantly tell the men we work with at Cinqe Matchmaking that women appreciate a man with a plan.
You don’t need to spend a fortune. You just need to make an effort.
I understand the other side of this argument.
A man might be going on several first dates before meeting someone he genuinely connects with.
He doesn’t necessarily want to commit to a three-hour dinner with a complete stranger.
And frankly, neither should a woman if she’s not interested.
That’s why drinks can be a great first date.
You can meet at a beautiful hotel bar, order a cocktail or something nonalcoholic, and spend an hour getting to know each other.
If the chemistry isn’t there, you can politely end the evening.
If you’re enjoying yourselves, you can always extend the date.
The important thing is that both people feel comfortable with the plan.

Here’s something I tell my male matchmaking clients.
Your job is to plan the date.
Don’t send a woman ten messages asking where she wants to go, what neighborhood she prefers, or whether she wants drinks, dinner, coffee, or a walk.
Of course, ask about any dietary restrictions or practical preferences.
But take the initiative.
Something as simple as suggesting a beautiful restaurant and offering two times works.
You don’t need to create an elaborate experience. You just need to show that you’re capable of making a plan.
And please, don’t turn the first date into a job interview or a therepy session.
I see this happen constantly with successful professionals.
They’re so accustomed to interviewing people, evaluating opportunities, and making business decisions that they bring the same energy into dating.
A first date is not a time to interview or get free therapy advice.
Relax. Laugh. Flirt. Enjoy yourself.

It’s not choosing drinks over dinner.
It’s spending too much time communicating before you’ve actually met.
I tell our clients that excessive texting and long phone conversations before a first date can create false intimacy.
You start imagining a relationship with someone you haven’t even met.
You might have incredible conversations over text and absolutely no chemistry in person.
That’s why I recommend keeping any initial phone or video conversation relatively short.
Confirm that there’s mutual interest, establish a little banter, and make plans to meet.
The real connection needs to happen in person.
Our Instagram poll showed that 55% of respondents preferred dinner, while 45% preferred drinks.
To me, that says something important.
There isn’t one universally correct first date.
Some people appreciate the commitment of dinner. Others prefer the flexibility of drinks.
What matters more is the thought behind the invitation.
I’ve arranged dates at beautiful restaurants, casual neighborhood spots, hotel lounges, and everything in between.
I’ve also watched incredible relationships begin with very ordinary first dates.
The venue isn’t what creates chemistry.
The people do.
But if you’re a man asking for my personal advice?
Make a reservation somewhere nice, have a plan, and show up ready to have a good time.
That’s a pretty good start.
Cinqe Matchmaking is a private luxury matchmaking firm founded in 2010 by professional matchmaker Erica Arrechea.
We work with accomplished singles seeking meaningful relationships through personalized matchmaking, private introductions, and a human approach to dating.
Our matchmaking services are available across the United States and internationally.
Discover Cinqe’s private matchmaking experience and learn how our team can help you approach your personal life with the same intention you’ve brought to your career. Contact us here.
Related Articles
Stay up to date with our latest happenings and receive the inside scoop.