
By Erica Arrechea, Founder of Cinqe Matchmaking
The word “vetted” scares me.
There. I said it.
If you’ve spent any time researching luxury matchmaking companies, you’ve probably seen it everywhere.
“All our members are vetted.”
“We have an exclusive database of vetted singles.”
“Meet pre-screened, vetted professionals.”
Matchmakers LOVE this word. And here’s the funny part.
I’ve been using it too ... well we don’t actually use it anymore.
I’ve been a professional matchmaker for 16 years, and recently I started thinking about how casually our industry throws around the word “vetted.”
Including me!
And I realized something. I made a mistake.
Not necessarily in how we screen singles at Cinqe, but in assuming everyone understood what I meant when I said someone was vetted.
Because what does that actually mean?
And more importantly, what does the PUBLIC think it means?

Let’s say you’re paying a luxury matchmaking company $50,000 to find you a partner.
The matchmaker tells you, “Don’t worry, everyone we introduce you to has been vetted.”
Great! Sounds reassuring, right?
But what exactly are you paying for?
Does vetted mean the person had a 30-minute Zoom interview?
Does it mean someone checked their LinkedIn profile?
Verified their identity?
Confirmed they’re actually single TODAY?
Ran a criminal background check?
Looked for restraining orders? Domestic violence charges? Sexual assault allegations? Harassment complaints?
What about civil lawsuits?
What about something that happened in another state? Or another country?
And here’s another one.
Does vetted mean someone has confirmed the person is who they claim to be financially?
Because that’s a whole different conversation.
These are all VERY different levels of screening.
And yet we’re using the same word to describe them.
When a matchmaking company advertises that its entire database is vetted, I wonder what the average consumer assumes.
Do they think every person has passed a comprehensive background check?
That someone has verified their marital status?
That there’s no history of violence or harassment?
That the company has investigated every possible red flag?
I genuinely don’t know.
But I suspect the public’s definition of vetted and the matchmaking industry’s definition might be two completely different things???
And that concerns me.
Because when someone hires a professional matchmaker, they’re trusting us with something incredibly personal.
Their dating life. Their time. Their emotions. Sometimes their physical safety.
We should be VERY careful about creating a sense of security that goes beyond what we’ve actually verified.
I’ll admit something.
We’ve used the word “vetted” on our own website. Again, we dont anymore.
And for a long time, I didn’t think twice about it.
To me, vetting meant getting to know someone, asking questions, looking for inconsistencies, evaluating their intentions, and conducting whatever screening was appropriate for the situation.
But I never really stopped to consider what someone reading our website might assume.
Maybe they thought every single person in our database had undergone a criminal background check.
(checkout my conversation with FBI investigator Tom Simon here)
Maybe they assumed we’d verified everyone’s income, marital status, and entire legal history.
And if that’s what someone understood from our marketing, then we weren’t being clear enough.
That’s on us.
We have different types of people in our database. Some are paying clients working directly with our matchmaking team. Others have simply applied to be considered for introductions.
Those are not the same thing.
And it would be misleading to suggest that everyone has gone through an identical screening process.
I’ve realized that saying someone is vetted isn’t enough. We need to explain what that actually means.
It’s a change I’m making in how we communicate at Cinqe.
No.
And I wish more people understood this.
A background check can be an incredibly useful tool. Depending on the type of search, it may uncover criminal convictions, certain court records, or other publicly available information.
But it has limitations.
Not every allegation results in criminal charges.
Not every arrest leads to a conviction.
Not every record is publicly accessible.
Records can be incomplete, outdated, sealed, or difficult to locate.
And searching records across multiple states or countries can be complicated.
Here’s something else.
A clean background check does NOT mean someone is a good person.
It doesn’t mean they’re faithful.
It doesn’t mean they’re emotionally available.
It doesn’t mean they’re honest about their intentions.
And it certainly doesn’t guarantee they’ll treat you well.
I’ve been doing this for 16 years. Some of the most important things we learn about people don’t come from a database.
They come from conversations.
Asking questions.
Paying attention.
Noticing when someone’s story doesn’t add up.
And sometimes, simply trusting our professional judgment enough to ask another question.
But even with years of experience, no matchmaker can predict someone’s future behavior.
We’re matchmakers. Not fortune tellers.
This is another question I get ALL the time.
“How do you know your clients aren’t married?”
The answer might surprise you.
There isn’t one universal database where a matchmaker can enter someone’s name and instantly confirm their current marital status across every jurisdiction.
Marriage and divorce records are handled differently depending on the location.
Some are public. Some have restricted access. Some require additional identifying information.
And even if you find a divorce record, that doesn’t necessarily tell you everything about someone’s current relationship status.
So what do we do?
We ask questions.
LOOOOTS of them.
We get to know our clients. We learn about their lives, their families, their schedules, their previous relationships, and what they’re looking for.
And when something doesn’t make sense, we ask more questions.
Can someone lie to a matchmaker?
Of course.
People can lie to their attorneys, their doctors, their friends, and their spouses.
But the more involved you become in someone’s life, the harder it can be to maintain a false story.
That’s one of the advantages of working with an actual human matchmaker.
Still, it isn’t a guarantee.
And I would never want someone to believe otherwise.
This is something I’ve started thinking about more seriously.
I’m not an attorney, so I’m not going to pretend to give legal advice.
But I do think it’s a question our industry should be asking.
If a matchmaking company advertises that every member is vetted, but its screening consists of a short phone interview, could that create a misleading impression?
What if a consumer reasonably believes that vetted means criminal background checked?
What if the company never explains what its screening actually includes?
The word itself isn’t automatically misleading. The issue is what a company communicates, what consumers reasonably understand, and whether its actual practices support those claims.
I think matchmaking companies should be discussing this with their attorneys instead of simply copying language from competitors’ websites.
Especially when we’re dealing with people’s personal safety.

If you’re considering hiring a professional matchmaking company, I would encourage you to ask a few questions before signing a contract.
1. When you say your members are vetted, what exactly does that mean?
Ask them to walk you through the actual process.
2. Do you run criminal background checks?
If yes, on whom? Paying clients? Complimentary database members? Everyone? And at what stage?
3. Do you verify identity and marital status?
If so, how?
4. Do you conduct screening in every country where you operate?
International background checks can have very different limitations.
5. What happens if you discover something concerning?
Does the company have a process for evaluating serious red flags?
6. Are the people in your complimentary database screened differently from paying clients?
This is a BIG one.
There’s nothing inherently wrong with having different screening procedures for different types of members.
But consumers should understand those differences.
And please remember, no amount of screening replaces your own judgment when meeting someone new.
I’m not writing this because I think matchmaking companies are intentionally misleading people.
I’m writing it because I realized just how differently people can interpret one little word.
And if I’ve been doing this for 16 years and still find myself questioning the language our industry uses, I imagine other matchmakers might benefit from asking the same questions.
At Cinqe, we actually define what we mean by “vetted” in our website FAQs. We explain what our screening process involves, what we look into, and the limitations of that process.
But this whole conversation made me realize something. Just because we explain it somewhere on our website doesn't mean everyone reading the word “vetted” understands what we mean.
And I think that's where our industry needs to be more careful.
What have we actually checked?
What haven't we checked?
And what can we realistically guarantee?
Because I don't think consumers need another fancy marketing word.
They need information. They need transparency. And they deserve to understand what they're actually paying for.
The question shouldn't be, “Does your matchmaking company vet its members?”
The question should be, “What exactly have you done when you tell me someone has been vetted?”
I'd love to hear what you think.
When YOU hear that a matchmaking company has vetted someone, what do you assume they've actually done?
Because I have a feeling we're going to get some very different answers.
Erica Arrechea is the founder of Cinqe Matchmaking, a luxury matchmaking company serving clients across the United States and internationally. She has worked as a professional matchmaker for 16 years.
Successful in business. Ready for something more?
Discover Cinqe’s private matchmaking experience and learn how our team can help you approach your personal life with the same intention you’ve brought to your career. Contact us here.
Related Articles
Stay up to date with our latest happenings and receive the inside scoop.